Best Eyeliners in India
Maybelline’s Colossal Kajal Eyeliner Pencil ranks #39 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory with by far the strongest current sales in this roundup at over 14,306 units a month and by far the largest review base at over 60,141 reviews, while Lakme’s 9to5 Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner ranks #3 with the second-strongest sales at over 6,835 units a month — real evidence that both a mainstream kajal pencil and a precision liquid liner have genuinely large audiences. This roundup covers four eyeliners spanning a kajal pencil, a liquid liner, and two felt-tip pen formats.
Each targets a different real preference between applicator format, price, and finish.
How to Pick an Eyeliner
- Kajal pencils, like the Maybelline pick, are genuinely the easiest applicator format for quick, everyday use, a real beginner-friendly choice.
- Liquid liners, like the Lakme pick, genuinely offer more precise, defined lines for a sharper look than a pencil.
- Felt-tip pen liners, used by the Swiss Beauty and MARS picks, genuinely combine some of the precision of liquid with easier control than a traditional brush applicator.
- Waterproof and smudge-proof formulas, used across all four picks here, are a genuine baseline expectation for long-wear eyeliner in India’s humid climate.
- Checking subcategory rank, as used throughout this roundup, helps separate genuinely top-selling eyeliner brands from smaller, less-established ones.
4 Eyeliners from Mainstream Kajal Pencils to Precision Liquid Liners
Maybelline Colossal Kajal Pencil — #39 in Eyeliners, By Far Strongest Sales & Most Reviewed
This ranks #39 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory with by far the strongest current sales in this roundup at over 14,306 units a month and by far the largest review base at over 60,141 reviews. Its genuine kajal pencil format with a matte finish is the easiest, most mainstream applicator for quick everyday use.
Its precision trails the liquid and pen formats of the other three picks, being a softer, less sharply defined line.
Best for: buyers who want the easiest, most mainstream everyday applicator
- 👍 By far the strongest current sales in this roundup, over 14,306 units a month
- 👍 By far the largest review base in this roundup, over 60,141 reviews
- 👍 Genuine kajal pencil format, the easiest everyday applicator
- 👎 Precision trails the liquid and pen formats of the other three picks
- 👎 Matte pencil finish, for buyers wanting a sharper liquid line
Lakme 9to5 Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner — #3 in Eyeliners, Precision Pick
This ranks #3 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory with the second-strongest current sales in this roundup at over 6,835 units a month. Being genuinely from Lakme, a mainstream Indian cosmetics brand, its liquid formula with a quick-dry, waterproof finish offers a real sharper, more precisely defined line than a pencil.
Its review base trails the Maybelline pick, though its #3 subcategory rank leads all but the Maybelline pencil.
Best for: buyers who want a sharp, precisely defined liquid line
- 👍 Ranks #3 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory
- 👍 Second-strongest current sales in this roundup, over 6,835 units a month
- 👍 Genuine liquid formula for a sharper, precisely defined line
- 👎 Review base trails the Maybelline pick
- 👎 Liquid format requires more applicator control than a pencil
Swiss Beauty Felt Tip Pen Eyeliner — #7 in Eyeliners, Budget Pen Format
This ranks #7 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory with solid current sales at over 4,141 units a month. Its genuine felt-tip pen applicator offers easier control than a liquid brush, at a real budget-friendly price.
Its review base trails the Maybelline and Lakme picks, reflecting a smaller but growing audience for this specific alt-brand format.
Best for: buyers who want an easier-to-control pen applicator at a budget price
- 👍 Ranks #7 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory
- 👍 Genuine felt-tip pen applicator, easier control than a liquid brush
- 👍 Budget-friendly price point
- 👎 Review base trails the Maybelline and Lakme picks
- 👎 Current sales trail the Maybelline and Lakme picks
MARS City Stroke Liquid Eyeliner — #8 in Eyeliners, Alt-Brand Pen Format
This ranks #8 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory. Its genuine felt-tip design combined with a liquid formula offers a real hybrid of precise application and easier pen control, from MARS, a growing Indian cosmetics brand.
Its review base is the smallest in this roundup, reflecting a newer listing relative to the more established competitors here.
Best for: buyers who want a precise felt-tip pen from a growing alt-brand
- 👍 Ranks #8 in Amazon.in’s Eyeliners subcategory
- 👍 Genuine hybrid felt-tip-and-liquid design for precise application
- 👍 Solid rating at 4.1 stars
- 👎 Review base is the smallest in this roundup
- 👎 Current sales trail the other three picks
Frequently Asked Questions
Which eyeliner has the strongest sales on Amazon.in?
Maybelline’s Colossal Kajal Eyeliner Pencil has by far the strongest current sales in this roundup at over 14,306 units a month.
Which eyeliner has the most reviews?
Maybelline’s Colossal Kajal Pencil has by far the largest review base in this roundup at over 60,141 reviews.
Should I use a kajal pencil or a liquid eyeliner?
Kajal pencils, like the Maybelline pick, are genuinely easier for quick everyday use, while liquid liners, like the Lakme pick, offer a sharper, more precisely defined line.
What is a felt-tip pen eyeliner?
It’s a genuine hybrid applicator, used by the Swiss Beauty and MARS picks, combining some of the precision of a liquid liner with easier pen-style control than a brush.
Are these eyeliners waterproof?
Yes — all four picks in this roundup are genuinely marketed as waterproof and smudge-proof, a baseline expectation for long-wear eyeliner in India’s humid climate.
Which eyeliner is best for beginners?
Maybelline’s Colossal Kajal Pencil is genuinely the easiest applicator format for beginners, requiring less precision than a liquid or felt-tip pen.
Choosing Your Eyeliner
For the easiest everyday applicator, the strongest-selling Maybelline Colossal Kajal is the pick. Want a sharper, precisely defined line? Lakme’s 9to5 Liquid delivers. Need a budget-friendly pen format? Swiss Beauty’s felt-tip is worth it. And for a precise hybrid pen from a growing brand, MARS’ City Stroke rounds out this lineup.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. We don’t print prices or ratings here because they change daily; tap through to Amazon for the current price and latest reviews.
